Columbia High School
Annual Alumni vs Varsity Game

 

Year

Score

Winner

Notable Info

1st

1970

25-22

Alumni

First graduating class returns to scrimmage the Varsity. "The Alumni jump off to a 10-2 lead, but the Varsity players come back to take a 17 to 16 advantage before finally succumbing." (Larry & Paul Schindel)

2nd

1971

 

Varsity

In 1971 the Varsity consisting mainly of the same players as the year before, defeat the Alumni.

3rd

1972

22-20

Varsity

The legendary '72 team returns against their high school counterparts.

4th

1973

 

Alumni

 

5th

1974

 

Alumni

 

6th

1975

36-12

Alumni

 

7th

1976

 

Alumni

 

8th

1977

 

Alumni

 

9th

1978

23-22

Alumni

 

10th

1979

33-14 (?)

Alumni

 

11th

1980

 

Varsity

 

12th

1981

 

?

 

13th

1982

 

Alumni

 

14th

1983

 

Varsity

 

15th

1984

 

Alumni

 

16th

1985

 

Varsity

 

17th

1986

 

Alumni

 

18th

1987

 

Alumni

 

19th

1988

 

Alumni

 

20th

1989

 

Varsity

 

21st

1990

 

?

 

22nd

1991

 

Alumni

 

23rd

1992

 

Alumni

 

24th

1993

 

Alumni

 

25th

1994

 

Alumni

 

26th

1995

20-20

tie

 

27th

1996

 21-19

Alumni

 

28th

1997

21-5

Varsity

 

29th

1998

 21-11

Alumni

 

30th

1999

 21-10

Alumni

 

31st

2000

 21-15

Alumni

 

32nd

2001

21-9

Varsity

 

33rd

2002

21-19

Alumni

 

34th

2003

21-10

Alumni

 

35th

2004

21-15

Varsity

 

36th

2005

24-22

Varsity

 

37th

2006

21-19

Alumni

Pouring rain. Varsity ahead at half 11-7.

38th

2007

21-11

Varsity

Varsity went up 7-0 and took half 11-3. Weather: low 40s and strong gusty winds. Approximately 36 alums gathered to play. A few more in attendance. '72 grad Joe Barbanel's streak lives on. There is a growing buzz for next year. The 39th Annual and the 40th Anniversary.

39th

2008

21-17

Varsity

The CHS family had a competitive evening tonight. The Columbia '09 team took the first half 11-1. The playing time rotation amongst the Alumni was to play chronological order (beginning with the earliest classes first). First rotation saw John Newmark, '70, Joe Barbanel, '72, Ed Summers, '72, Robin Newmark, '74, Dave Paris, '79, Larry Anouna, '87, Alex Perry, '87. Three rotations in resulted in a hole for the Alums 0-9. The fourth rotation consisted mostly of the '08 class that won the UPA's HS Easterns championship last May. They only managed one point as the Currents closed out the half, 11-1. It was agreed-upon prior to the game that we would play with a strict chronological order in the first half and use the "super" teams in the second half. Second half saw younger athletic teams narrow the gap. Leading the charge was Emilio Panasci, '00 (currently plays for New York's PoNY) and Evan Padget, '05 (captain of Colorado Mamabird). Final score, 21-17 to the current team. One amazing second-half highlight that stands out was an Alumni score on an Ed Frowely, '03, catch in the corner of the endzone (nearest to the Rock) and inches from the brook. Ed's defender, senior Jordan Taylor, '09, narrowly missed the D on a horizontal layout only to find his body falling into the brook. More amazingly, Jordan landed and with his momentum jumped over to the other side of the brook. None of the alums can ever recall a similar incident happening.

40th

2009

15-13

Varsity

The Maplewood police paid a visit around 10:30, reporting the neighbors were complaining about noise. They insisted on shutting the game down at 11pm. At 11 o'clock, the Varsity was ahead at 15-13. This is the Varsity's unprecedented third victory in a row ('07, '08, '09). Five wins in the last six years. All-time series record is 24-13-1. (1981 and 1990 results still unknown). In the first 20 years, the Alumni had won 13 times and the Varsity 6. In the second 20 years, the Alumni have won 11 times and the Varsity 7 times and together tied once.


Joe Seidler donating Ultimate History.......................................................Buzzy Hellring's sister
Book to CHS Librarian.........................................................................with his frisbee

Ultimate Reunion Article


© 2010 Ultimate History. All rights reserved. Privacy policy. Site maintained by Seidler Consulting.